I-95 Underride Guards: Why 2026 Rules Fall Short

Listen to this article · 9 min listen

People have been fighting for better truck safety for decades, but the myths about underride guard effectiveness and what makes truck accident fatalities preventable just won’t die. This misinformation clouds the grim reality we see on highways like I-95 in Savannah. Frankly, what most people think they know about large truck safety, especially when a car slides under a trailer, is just wrong.

Key Takeaways

  • Federal law requires rear underride guards, but the current standard (FMVSS 223) is so weak that guards often fail in real-world crashes, leading to horrific injuries and death.
  • The Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS) has proven that stronger underride guards, which go way beyond the federal minimum, dramatically cut the risk of a car sliding underneath a trailer.
  • The U.S. does not have any federal mandate for side underride guards, leaving a massive, deadly gap in safety that has been proven effective at stopping catastrophic side-impacts.
  • In Georgia, victims of underride accidents can file personal injury claims for negligence, defective products, or for violations of safety laws like those covered in O.C.G.A. Section 51-1-6.
  • Advocates are pushing hard at the federal and state level for stronger rear guards and mandated side guards to make our highways safer.

Myth 1: All Underride Guards Are Equally Safe and Prevent Fatalities

A huge misconception is that just because the government mandates rear underride guards on tractor-trailers, they all provide solid protection. That’s not even close to true. The governing rule, Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standard (FMVSS) 223, only sets a bare-minimum performance level that most experts agree is dangerously inadequate. While the guards have to withstand some force in a lab test, the physics of a high-speed crash, particularly an offset impact where a car only hits a corner of the guard, blows right past these design limits. I’ve seen the aftermath when a modern car’s roof is sheared completely off because the underride guard simply buckled and broke away.

The Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS) proved this gap with extensive crash testing. Their research shows many guards that meet the federal minimum still crumple in moderate-overlap tests, allowing the car to slide underneath. An IIHS report notes that while most new trailers have “Good” or “Acceptable” guards now, that’s a recent development, and our roads are still full of older trailers with junk guards. The real-world physics of a small vehicle hitting a massive, high-riding truck are what matter. The forces involved in those wrecks just blow past what these minimum-standard guards can handle, causing them to bend, break, or shear off completely.

Feature Current FMVSS 223 Rear Guards IIHS “Good” Rated Rear Guards Side Underride Guards
Federally Mandated in U.S. ✓ Yes ✗ No ✗ No
Prevents Underride in Offset Impacts ✗ No (often fail) ✓ Yes (significant reduction) ✓ Yes (prevents catastrophic side-impacts)
Addresses Rear-End Collisions ✓ Yes (minimum standard) ✓ Yes (exceeds minimum) ✗ No (focus on side)
Addresses Side-Impact Collisions ✗ No ✗ No ✓ Yes
Effectiveness in High-Speed Crashes Partial (often overwhelmed) ✓ Yes (stronger performance) ✓ Yes (proven effectiveness)
Subject of NTSB Safety Recommendations ✗ No (focus on inadequacy) ✗ No (IIHS advocacy) ✓ Yes (repeated calls for protection)

Myth 2: Underride Guards Are Only a Concern for Rear-End Collisions

Most people only think about underride in rear-end crashes because that’s the only place the federal rule applies. This completely ignores the nightmare scenario of a side underride. When a car hits the side of a semi-trailer, maybe during a turn or a lane change, there is absolutely nothing there to stop it from sliding right under. This is a constant danger on busy roads like I-95 near Savannah, where trucks constantly merge and navigate interchanges, creating big blind spots and tight situations.

A side underride isn’t like a rear-end hit where even a weak guard might slow the car down a little. In a side underride, the car’s roof can be peeled back like a can opener as it goes under the trailer, leaving the people inside with no protection at all from the trailer’s frame. The National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) has been practically begging for side underride protection for years because of its potential to save lives. Their 2020 Safety Recommendation Report on Underride Protection spelled out this exact vulnerability. Even with those recommendations and proven side guard technology available, there’s still no federal rule requiring them in the U.S. It’s a massive, deadly blind spot in our safety regulations.

Myth 3: Drivers Are Always to Blame in Underride Accidents

It’s easy to blame the car’s driver in an underride crash, but that ignores the systemic failures that set the stage for disaster. The truck’s design and its (often missing) safety equipment are huge factors. If a truck’s guard fails in a crash that was maybe unavoidable because of a sudden traffic stop or bad weather, is the car’s driver really 100% at fault for the fatal result? The blame just doesn’t hold up.

And what about other factors? Things like broken or dim lights on a trailer, a truck driver making an improper lane change, or a semi parked illegally on a shoulder or on-ramp (which you see all the time near Georgia’s distribution hubs) can start the chain reaction that ends in an underride. When you have a driver making a common mistake near a truck with a guard that’s basically for show, people die. In Georgia, a victim’s family can bring a negligence claim if the truck driver’s choices or the company’s bad policies caused the wreck. This can involve breaking federal trucking rules from the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA) or just simple state traffic laws. The legal reality is far more complicated than just saying “the car hit the truck.”

Myth 4: There’s Nothing That Can Be Done After an Underride Accident

This myth is dangerous because it makes people give up before they even start. After the devastation of an underride accident, victims and their families absolutely have legal options. In Georgia, if a defective guard, a negligent driver, or a company’s failure to maintain its trucks causes an underride, you can take legal action. A personal injury claim can recover money for medical bills, lost income, suffering, and in the worst cases, wrongful death damages to provide for a family’s future.

The makers of faulty underride guards can also be sued under product liability laws. If a guard didn’t do its job, or if the manufacturer had a stronger, safer design but chose not to use it to save a few bucks, they can be held responsible. This area of law gets complicated fast, demanding expert testimony on everything from metallurgy and guard design to accident reconstruction physics. Trucking companies also have a duty to keep their fleet safe and compliant. Failing to do so is negligence. Georgia law, under O.C.G.A. Section 51-1-6, specifically lets people recover damages from another’s negligence, which absolutely applies here. Assuming there’s no path forward is a mistake. The first step should always be talking to an attorney specializing in truck accidents.

Myth 5: Stricter Underride Guard Regulations Would Be Too Costly for the Trucking Industry

The go-to argument from the trucking industry against better underride guards is always cost. This position conveniently ignores the staggering human cost of using cheap, ineffective guards. Yes, stronger rear guards or new side guards cost money upfront, but that investment pays for itself by saving lives, preventing catastrophic injuries, and reducing the massive legal liability that comes from these wrecks. The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA), the agency that sets these standards, does a cost-benefit analysis for every rule. The NTSB has also said again and again that the cost of side guards is small compared to the cost to society of the deaths and injuries they would prevent. The industry’s cost argument conveniently leaves out all the other expenses society picks up: the bills for first responders, long-term medical care, lost wages, and the financial ruin that families face.

Besides, many forward-thinking trucking companies and trailer manufacturers already use stronger designs that exceed the federal minimums, and they haven’t gone out of business. They know that investing in safety is a smart business move that lowers their risk. The idea that we have to choose between profit and safety is a false choice, we can and must have both.

To stop these horrific and preventable tragedies on Georgia’s roads, we have to look at the facts about underride guard failures, not tired old myths. We need better safety standards, real enforcement, and more public awareness.

What is an underride guard?

It’s a safety device, usually a steel bar setup, on the back (and sometimes sides) of big trucks and their trailers. It’s supposed to keep a smaller car from sliding underneath the trailer during a crash, which is what causes the most catastrophic injuries like decapitation.

Are side underride guards legally required in Georgia or federally?

No. The U.S. has no federal mandate for side underride guards, and Georgia has no specific state law requiring them either. The only federally required guard is on the rear of the trailer, under the weak FMVSS 223 standard.

What is the “IIHS Good” rating for underride guards?

An IIHS “Good” rating means a rear underride guard held up strong in all three of the institute’s crash tests: full-width, 50% overlap, and 30% overlap. These tests are much tougher and more realistic than the government’s minimum standard, FMVSS 223, because they simulate different angles of impact.

Can I file a lawsuit if I was injured in an underride accident in Savannah?

Yes. If you or a loved one was hurt in an underride wreck in Savannah, you likely have a good case for a personal injury lawsuit. You could have claims against the truck driver for negligence, the trucking company for poor maintenance or policies, and even the guard manufacturer for a defective product. You should speak with an experienced lawyer to go over the details.

What Georgia laws apply to truck accidents involving underride?

Georgia’s general negligence laws, like O.C.G.A. Section 51-1-6, allow you to recover damages when someone else’s carelessness causes harm. In truck accident cases, federal regulations from the FMCSA and state traffic laws are also critical for proving who was at fault and liable for the underride collision.

Editorial Team

The Editorial Team at Truck Accident Georgia is a group of writers and editors who cover personal injury and workplace law in Georgia. They research each story and publish under a shared desk byline — experts in their fields, working as one team.